FUJ00122794
FUJ00122794
Message
From: Jones David M [/O=EXCHANGE/OU=ADMINGROUP1/CN=RECIPIENTS/CN=DJ]
Sent: 05/02/2010 17:10:19
To: ‘jarnail.a.singhi_
cc: Jenkins Gareth Gt Thomas Penny
J
Subject: RE: WEST BYFLEET ISSUES - SEEMA MISRA - Legally Privileged
Importance: High
Jarnail
This is an email that I received earlier from Gareth. You will see that he is clear that in order to answer Counsel's
question about any issues he needs to be able to check the underlying transaction logs to be able to say whether there
were any issues. On the specific issues you raise Gareth's view is:
2. He needs information and time to research the background to this case before providing any response;
3. He is not currently in a position to make a clear statement. It is possible for there to be problems where
transactions have been “lost” in particular circumstances due to locking issues. When this happens then we have
events in the underlying eventing logs to indicate that there was an issue. Whenever we provide transaction logs
to POL we check for any such events. In the case of West Byfleet we have not been asked to provide any
transaction logs and so have not made these checks.
4. Gareth has reviewed the statement by Eleanor Nixon. There is nothing technical there for him to
comment on. If POL are able to expand on exactly what they did to resolve the issues and what they found to be
the issues there, then he could comment on that. At first glance it is purely a case of incorrect use of the system
and clearly with any system if incorrect information is input then incorrect results come out.
I hope that helps.
David
David M Jones, Head of Legal
UK Private Sector Division
FUJITSU
From: Jenkins Gareth GI
Sent: 05 February 2010 16:06
To: Jones David M; Thomas Penny
Subject: RE: WEST BYFLEET ISSUES - SEEMA MISRA - Legally Privileged
David / Penny,
Brief responses as follows, but not sure that I should put them in a Witness Statement:
2. I need [Jones David M] information and time to research the background to this case
before providing any response
3. This is where I'm reluctant to make a clear statement. I am aware of one problem
where transactions have been lost in particular circumstances due to locking
issues. When this happens we have events in the eventing logs to indicate that there was
an issue and whenever we provide transaction logs to POL we check for any such
FUJ00122794
FUJ00122794
events. In the case of West Byfleet we have not provided any transaction logs and so
have not made these checks.
4, I have reviewed the statement by Eleanor Nixon. There is nothing technical there
for me to comment on. If POL are able to expand on exactly what they did to resolve the
issues and what they found to be the issues there, then I could comment on that. At
first glance it is purely a case of incorrect use of the system and clearly with any
system if incorrect information is input then incorrect results come out.
If you feel it OK to pass this onto POL then that’s fine by me, but I’m reluctant for it
to go further without POL’s agreement and understanding of the potential implications.
David
David M Jones, Head of Legal
UK Private Sector Division
FUSTSU
Swan House, The Cau:
tse GRO
iipiuic Fajitsucom
Stairs
it
This e-mail is only for the use of its intended recipient. Its contents are subject to a duty of confidence and may be privileged. Fujitsu Services does
not guarantee that this e-mail has not been intercepted and amended or that it is virus-free.
none Original Message-----
From: marilyn.benjami GRO, 4 on Behalf Of
jarnail.a.singhf
Sent: 05 February
To: Jones David M
Cc: Jenkins Gareth GI; Thomas Penny
Subject: WEST BYFLEET ISSUES - SEEMA MISRA - Legally Privileged
Dear David and Penny,
On first glance points 2 - 4 have not been answered which I reproduce
below.
2) My barrister telephoned me yesterday evening and requested that I find
out any information that Fujitsu may hold in relation to an office called
Callender Square in Falkirk. Apparently, Anne Chambers a Systems
Specialist employed by Fujitsu was cross examined and it is said that she
had full knowledge of an error in the Horizon system at this Post Office.
Our barrister would like Gareth to deal with this matter and expand upon
whatever issue Anne Chambers raised at court within his witness statement.
3) When Gareth completes his statement could he also mention whether there
are any known problems with the Horizon system that Fujitsu are aware of.
If none could this be clarified in the statement.
4) Could Gareth read the statement from Eleanor Nixon attached below and
respond in his statement to the points raised by Eleanor Nixon about
Horizon.
(See attached file: Eleanor Nixon Statement.rtf)
Could you please give this matter your urgent attention and look forward to
FUJ00122794
FUJ00122794
hearing from you.
Jarnail A Singh
Senior Lawyer
Criminal Law Team
Tel.No:
Fax.No:
FEI III III III II III III I ISIS III IIIS III I I i ik
Royal Mail Group Limited registered in England and Wales registered number
4138203 registered office 3rd Floor, 100 Victoria Embankment, London, EC4Y¥
oHQ
This email and any attachments are confidential and intended for the
addressee only. If you are not the named recipient, you must not use,
disclose, reproduce, copy or distribute the contents of this communication.
If you have received this in error, please contact the sender and then
delete this email from your system.
JESUS GOES ISIE ISHS SISSIES IIS ISIS ISG ISIS ISIS bib Rie