POLB 14(4"")
POLB 14/48-14/63
Minutes of a Board meeting held on 30 April 2014
at 148 Old Street, London EC1V 9HQ
Present:
Alice Perkins
Neil McCausland
Tim Franklin
Virginia Holmes
Alasdair Marnoch
Richard Callard
Paula Vennells
Chris Day
In Attendance:
Alwen Lyons
Nick Kennett
Chris Aujard
Paul Havenhand
Mark Davies
Martin George
Kevin Gilliland
Lesley Sewell
Gareth James
POLB 14/48
(a)
POLB 14/49
(a)
(b)
ACTION: Nick
Kennett
Post Office Limited — Strictly Confidential
Chairman
Non-Executive Director
Non-Executive Director
Non-Executive Director (minutes 14/49-14/51)
Non-Executive Director
Non-Executive Director
Chief Executive
Chief Financial Officer
INTRODUCTION
A quorum being present, the Chairman opened the meeting and
welcomed Nick Kennett, Director, Financial Services, Chris Aujard,
General Counsel, and Paul Havenhand, Head of Travel and
Insurance.
PROJECT TITAN
The Board received an update on Project Titan. Virginia Holmes,
Chairman of the Board FS Sub Committee, explained that Titan had
been discussed at the recent Sub Committee and that there was
support for the project subject to the outcome of additional work on
governance and risk.
The Board acknowledged the importance of Titan in delivering the FS
strategy. However, it recognised the risks to the Post Office brand and
reputation of establishing the specialist subsidiary Managing General
Agent (MGA). The Business was asked to provide more detail of the
POL00150285
POL00150285
POST OFFICE LIMITED
(Company no. 2154540)
(the ‘Company’)
Company Secretary
Director, Financial Services (minutes 14/48-49, 14/51 and
14/53)
General Counsel (minutes 14/48-49 and 14/55)
Head of Travel and Insurance (minute 14/48-49)
Communications and Corporate Affairs Director (minutes
14/50 and 14/52)
Chief Marketing and Commercial Officer (minutes 14/53-54)
Network & Sales Director (minutes 14/53-54)
Chief Information Officer (minute 14/55)
Partner, Deloitte LLP (minute 14/55)
POL-BSFF-0009403
POL00150285
POL00150285
Post Office Limited — Strictly Confidential
financial impacts of the proposed model.
ACTION: Chris
Aujard
ACTION:
Company (d) Virginia Holmes suggested that the Miller Report used by the FS Sub
Secretary Committee be made available to the full Board.
{e) The Business was asked to provide a paper for the next Board
covering:
« the governance structure of the MGA. How the relationship,
controls and oversights between the MGA Board and the Post
Office Board would operate and link through to the
Shareholder Executive;
e. the implications for the Business of operating the MGA
including the change in the risk profile;
* an analysis of the financial impacts of the new operating
model, including improved margins and higher costs and how
ACTION: these relate to the additional risk, bearing in mind all the other
Nick Kennett! changes that the Business was committed to implementing;
Chris Aujard/ and
Chris Day * an analysis of the Business’ current regulatory obligations
compared to a position of becoming directly regulated.
ACTION:
Chris Aujard
(9). Without prejudice to the discussions at the next Board meeting, the
Board authorised the Business to:
(i) Utilise the Post Office Management Services Limited (“POMS”)
to be the Post Office Managing General Agent; and
(il) Discuss with BIS the possible use of POMS and understand
the governance for appointing Directors which would be
discussed at the next Board meeting.
(h) Nick Kennett, Chris Aujard and Paul Havenhand left the meeting.
POLB 14/50 MILESTONES TO MUTUALISATION
(a) Mark Davies, Communications and Corporate Affairs Director, joined
the meeting
(b) The Board discussed the Milestones to Mutualisation document, which
set out the conditions necessary before the mutualisation of Post
Office Limited could become a reality.
(c) Richard Callard explained the Minister's desire to publish this
document, by the end of the week, alongside the announcements of
the Community Fund and the Post Office Public Purpose.
POL-BSFF-0009403_0001
POL00150285
POL00150285
Post Office Limited — Strictly Confidential
(d) Mark Davies pointed out that the Business had always planned to
announce the Milestones to Mutualisation in the first quarter of the
financial year 2014/15, but he had some reservations of doing so at
present because of the possible connection with the mutual model at
the Co-operative Group and the current publicity about them.
(e) The Board discussed the document and agreed some amendments.
(f} The Board agreed that the document could be published alongside the
ACTION: Post Office Public Purpose and Community Fund announcement but
Richard Callard asked Richard Callard to feed back to BIS the Board’s view that the
emphasis in any statement be on the Community Funds and Public
Purpose Statement, as these were the current issues.
({g) Mark Davies left the meeting.
POLB 14/51 VARIOUS FINANCIAL SERVICES ISSUES
(a) Nick Kennett re-joined the meeting.
(b) The Board discussed the areas for debate with the guests from the
Bank of Ireland joining the meeting. The Chairman recognised the
commitment from the Bank and the strength of the relationship. It was
agreed to test the alignment of the two Business’ plans, the support
for the growth strategy and the appetite for investment products.
(c) Virginia Holmes left the meeting.
(d) The Board noted the Analysis of the Post Office relationship with the
Co-operative Group, which had been circulated as a noting paper.
(e) The Board asked if there was any more the Business could do to
protect itself from the current exposure to the Co-operative Group.
The CFO explained that he had commissioned a piece of work from
Thomson Reuters to evaluate the current position and propose an
appropriate approach to give the Business financial protection. The
Board asked the CFO to share the outcome of the report and the
ACTION: CFO actions he decides to take with Alasdair Marnoch, Chairman of the
Audit Committee and the General Counsel.
(f} I The Board noted the update on various risk matters, including Bank of
Ireland (UK) plc capital & liquidity and the progress on the launch of a
Financial Services Sub-Brand. The Board discussed the Sub Brand
options and supported the proposal of Post Office Money.
(g) Nick Kennett left the meeting.
PUBLICATION OF ANNUAL REPORT AND FINANCIAL
POLB 14/52 STATEMENTS
(a) Mark Davies re-joined the meeting.
(b) The Board considered the plans for publication of the Post Office’s
Annual Report and Financial Statements for the financial year 2013-
2014. A detailed review would be carried out at the May ARC.
POL-BSFF-0009403_0002
POL00150285
POL00150285
Post Office Limited — Strictly Confidential
(c) The Board discussed the themes to be included in the Chairman's
ACTION: Mark foreword and CEO’s review and the desire to ensure that the whole
Davies/Chairman! report is fair, balanced and understandable, in line with best practice
CEO in corporate governance. Mark Davies would draft and agree these
before the ARC meeting.
ACTION: CFO (d) The CFO agreed to circulate a more detailed timetable to the Board.
(e) Mark Davies left the meeting.
POLB 14/53 COMMERCIAL UPDATE
(a) The Board welcomed Martin George, Chief Marketing and
Commercial Officer and Kevin Gilliland, Network & Sales Director.
Nick Kennett also re-joined the meeting.
(b) The Board congratulated Kevin Gilliland on the resolution of the CWU
pay dispute and recognised his personal commitment and that of his
team in delivering the agreement.
(c) Martin George updated the Board on the trading outlook and
explained the new governance now in place in the Business to drive
the commercial agenda. He reported changes in his team and
promised a greater focus on mails and a more robust engagement
with Royal Mail Group (RMG).
(d) The Board challenged the number and complexity of the products
which the Business sold. Whilst Kevin Gilliland agreed that simpler,
more automated products which were to the relevant to customer
would help his sales team, he did not advocate reducing products per
say.
ACTION: CFO (e) The Board asked the CFO to provide the product profitability analysis
for the next meeting.
(f) I Martin George emphasised the importance of mails to delivering this
ACTION: year’s income targets and suggested the he lead a deep dive into
Martin George mails at the May Board. This would include the relationship with RMG,
our response to changes in the market and how we can respond more
quickly.
(g) Martin George was confident in delivering the Government income in
2014/15. However, the current POCA negotiations could make future
years more difficult. The CFO stressed that any POCA contract would
need to have a long term positive margin and that the Business would
not agree a contract which was uneconomic. The CEO acknowledged
that the Department for Work and Pensions were in a difficult position
and reported that she had a meeting planned with the Pensions
Minister.
(h) Martin George was also confident in delivering the telephony income.
The Board asked for clarity on the reasons for the increase in the cost
ACTION: of sale versus the budget in the new telephony contract and the
Martin George reason why the Business has not been able to pass this on to the
POL-BSFF-0009403_0003
POL00150285
POL00150285
Post Office Limited — Strictly Confidential
supplier.
(i) Nick Kennett reported a strong final quarter in 2013/14 for Financial
Services which was generating a healthy pipeline for products in
2014/15. However the Life Assurance campaign was still being
analysed as this was an area which may need more work. He
stressed the reliance on delivering project such as Titan to support
this year's income.
(i) Nick Kennett left the meeting.
POLB 14/54 NETWORK AND SALES
(a) The Board received an update on the progress of Network
Transformation, discussions with the NFSP and Crown
Transformation, together with an update on Project Ivy.
(b) NETWORK TRANSFORMATION
The Board discussed the costs of onsite and offsite conversions and
the impact on sales. Kevin Gilliland explained that because of the
change of premises, offsite conversions were understandably taking
fonger to: recover lost sales as a resull of the change than onsite
conversions. The Business was trialling different initiatives to support
the new branches and he was very hopeful that this would improve the
sales.’ However, even with the initial loss of sales these branches
increased the profitability for the Post Office because of the savings in
fixed costs. The big opportunity for these branches was their
availability outside core Post Office hours and the Business needed to
promote that more effectively, as well as provide the right products
such as collections and returns.
ACTION: Kevin ()
Gilliland The Board asked for a further update on the economics of
transformed branches (onsite versus offsite) as part of the quarterly
Network update.
(d) Kevin Gilliland explained that, despite the success of hitting both the
number of contracts signed and branches open targets for 2013/14,
there was still considerable risk in this year's target as the majority.of
both contract signatures and openings would be Locals, particularly
onsite independent Locals, where this approach was largely untested
and could potentially take longer to deliver. He reported that he was
also working with the NFSP on a trial of ‘guided leavers’ using a
representative sample of 50 subpostmasters to show how we will
manage compulsory exits.
(e) CROWNS
Kevin Gilliland explained that the Business was now very clear about
the run rate required at March 2015 to deliver the target of a
breakeven Crown network. He stressed that the main risk to delivery
was the income line in the P&L, which required a 7% increase year on
year.
(f} The Board recognised the ambition in the plans and asked the
Business to work on a contingency to cover the risk of not achieving
ACTION: CFO the income target. The CFO explained that work was already
POL-BSFF-0009403_0004
POL00150285
POL00150285
Post Office Limited — Strictly Confidential
underway and a plan would be in place by the end of the first quarter.
The Board asked for sight of the work to date at the May meeting
(g) Chris Day reported that this methodology for calculating the exit run
rate for Crowns and therefore the breakeven point had been agreed
with BIS.
(h) PROJECT IVY
The Board noted the updates and the next steps for Project Ivy.
(i) I Martin George and Kevin Gilliland left the meeting.
POLB 14/55 HORIZON — DELOITTE REPORT
(a) The Board welcomed Lesley Sewell, Chief Information Officer, and
Gareth James, Partner, Deloilte, to the meeting. Chris Aujard also re-
Joined the meeting.
(b) ‘The Chairman thanked Gareth James for his draft report and
explained that there were a number of people who were sceptical
about Horizon. The Board were concerned to know the truth about
the reliability of the system. Deloitte’s views would need to be
expressed in such a way that they would persuade reasonable lay
people.
(c) Lesley Sewell explained that the first piece of work Deloitte had been
asked to undertake was to give assurance that the control framework,
including the security and processes for changes in the system, were
robust from an IT perspective.
{d) Gareth James reported that all the work to date showed that the
system had strong areas of control and that its testing and
implementation were in line with best practice. Work was still needed
to assure the controls and access at the Finance Service Centre.
(e) — Chris Aujard explained that several of the subpostmasters who were
challenging Horizon had made allegations about ‘phantom’
transactions which were non-traceable. Assurance from Deloitte about
the integrity of the system records logs would be very valuable.
ACTION: (f) The Board asked what assurance could be given pre 2010 when the
Lesley Sewell/ different Horizon system was in use, It was agreed that Gareth James
Chris Aujard would produce and cost a proposal for additional work to enable
assurance for the wider system, including pre 2010.
(g) Lesley Sewell, Gareth James and Chris Aujard left the meeting.
POLB 14/56 CHIEF EXECUTIVE’S REPORT
(a) The Board noted the Chief Executive's report.
{b) The CEO reported that an employee engagement score of 57% had
been achieved for the full year, which meant that the Business had
achieved its stretch target.
POL-BSFF-0009403_0005
POL00150285
POL00150285
Post Office Limited — Strictly Confidential
POLB 14/57 FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE UPDATE
(a) The Board received a financial performance update for March 2014.
POLB 14/58 MINUTES OF PREVIOUS MEETING AND MATTERS ARISING
(a) The minutes of the Board meeting held on 26 March 2014 were
approved for signature by the Chairman.
(b) There were no matters arising
POLB 14/59 COMMITTEE MEETING MINUTES FOR NOTING
(a) The Board noted the minutes of:
e the Audit, Risk and Compliance Committee meeting held on 6
March 2014;
« the Nominations Committee meeting held on 11 February
2014;
¢ the Pensions Committee meeting held on 5 March 2014; and
e the Remuneration Committee meeting held on 11 March 2014.
POLB 14/60 STATUS REPORT
(a) The Status Report, showing matters outstanding from previous Board
meetings, including an update on the Wave programme, was noted.
(b) It was noted that the Sparrow Lessons Learned review would be
discussed in more detail at the May ARC.
POLB 14/61 ITEMS FOR NOTING
(a) The Board noted the Separation update.
(b) The Board noted the Head Office relocation update. The Board asked
ACTION: CFO the Business to ensure it had negotiated the best rent available
including asking the landlord for rent free periods to vacant the old
building or for taking on the new lease. It was also suggested that the
Business should check the broadband capability of the new building.
(c) The Board noted the Significant Litigation report.
(d) The Board noted the Health & Safety report.
{e) The Board noted the update on Cyber Security and Information
Assurance.
(f) The Board noted the Report on Sealings and resolved that the
affixing of the Common Seal of the Company to the documents
set out against items numbered 1141 to 1159 inclusive in the seal
register was hereby confirmed.
POL-BSFF-0009403_0006
POLB 14/62
POLB 14/63
(a)
Post Office Limited — Strictly Confidential
ANY OTHER BUSINESS
There being no other business the meeting was closed
DATE OF NEXT MEETING
It was noted that the next Board meeting would be heid on 21 May
2014.
POL00150285
POL00150285
POL-BSFF-0009403_0007
000 €0%6000-44SE-10d
POL00150285
POL00150285
Post Office Limited — Strictly Confidential
POST OFFICE LIMITED 30 APRIL 2014 BOARD ACTION LOG
REFERENCE ACTION BY WHOM
Strategy
April 2014 Provide more detail of the financial impacts of the proposed model for Project Titan. Nick Kennett
POLB 14/49(b)
April 2014 Explain the extent to which the MGA would in reality be free from restrictions imposed on I Chris Aujard
POLB 14/49(c) government entities, including procurement law.
April 2014 Miller report to be made available to the full Board Company Secretary
POLB 14/49(d)
April 2014 Provide a paper for the next Board meeting covering: Nick Kennett/Chris
POLB 14/49(e)
e the governance structure of the MGA. How the relationship, controls and oversights
between the MGA Board and the Post Office Board would operate and link through to
the Shareholder Executive;
e the implications for the Business of operating the MGA including the change in the risk
profile;
* an analysis of the financial impacts of the new operating model, including improved
margins and higher costs and how these relate to the additional risk, bearing in mind
all the other changes that the Business was committed to implementing; and
* an analysis of the Business’ current regulatory obligations compared to a position of
becoming directly regulated.
Aujard/Chris Day
April 2014 Provide independent advice on the efficacy of the governance proposals, and to invite the I Chris Aujard
POLB 14/49(f) advisors to the next Board.
April 2014 Provide a product profitability analysis for the next meeting. CFO
POLB 14/53(e)
April 2014 Lead a deep dive into mails at the May Board Martin George
POLB 14/53(f)
April 2014 Provide clarity on the reasons for the increase in the cost of sale versus the budget in the new I Martin George
POLB 14/53(h)
telephony contract and the reason why the Business has not been able to pass this on to the
6000 €06000-44SE-10d
Post Office Limited — Strictly Confidential
POL00150285
POL00150285
supplier.
Finance
April 2014
POLB 14/52(c)
Draft and agree the themes to be included in the Chairman's foreword and CEO’s review and
the desire to ensure that the whole report is fair, balanced and understandable, in line with
best practice in corporate governance before the ARC meeting.
Mark
Davies/Chairman/CEO
April 2014 Circulate a more detailed timetable to the Board. CFO
POLB 14/52(d)
Network
April 2014 Provide a further update on the economics of transformed branches (onsite versus offsite) as I Kevin Gilliland
POLB 14/54(c) part of the quarterly Network update.
April 2014 Work to date on a contingency to cover the risk of not achieving the income target for the I CFO
POLB 14/54(f) Crown P&L to go to the May Board meeting.
Project Sparrow
April 2014 Gareth James to produce and cost a proposal for additional work to enable assurance for the I Lesley Sewell/Chris
POLB 14/55(f) wider system, including pre 2010. Aujard
Miscellaneous
April 2014 Feed back to BIS the Board's view that the emphasis in any statement be on the Community I Richard Callard
POLB 14/50(f) Funds and Public Purpose Statement, as these were the current issues.
April 2014 CFO to share the outcome of the Thomson Reuters report (on the current position and a I CFO
POLB 14/51(e) proposed approach to the Business’ relationship with the Co-operative Group) and the actions
he decides to take with Alasdair Marnoch, Chairman of the Audit Committee and the General
Counsel.
April 2014 The Business to ensure it had negotiated the best rent available for the head office relocation, I CFO
0100 €0%6000-44SE-10d
Post Office Limited — Strictly Confidential
POL00150285
POL00150285
POLB 14/61(b)
including asking the landlord for rent free periods to vacant the old building or for taking on the
new lease and the Business should check the broadband capability of the new building.